10 cigars with 90+ Ratings worth trying.

Finding a good cigar can be difficult when the range is as large as it is. Even though the blends are different in the cigars, many are incredibly similar to each other. What makes a cigar high on our list? A unique flavor profile that stands out from the crowd and quality that meets the highest standards.

Click on the images to read our in depth reviews

Table of Contents

Drew Estate blackened s84 shade to black toro

The Shade to Black is a standout Connecticut from Drew Estate, earning one of our top ratings. Bright raspberry-like acidity and sweet fruit tones meet refined flavors of coffee and herbs, creating a cigar that’s both unique and unforgettable.

El Septimo Da Vinci Lancero

You might not believe me without trying it yourself, but this cigar delivers something truly special. It’s complex and well-balanced, yet one flavor rises above the rest in a way that sets it apart. From the first draw to the final puff, a subtle coconut note develops and evolves, keeping you curious and engaged the whole way through. For the experience it offers, the price feels surprisingly modest.

Rebellion cigars 5 o clock somehwere

This cigar carries a fruitiness that really sets it apart — almost like a luxurious summer fruit salad. The profile is lighter in complexity, with a natural split into two distinct phases. It works just as well as an everyday smoke as it does for those moments when you want to treat yourself. Considering the quality, the price feels like a bargain.

Perdomo 20th anniversary maduro robusto

This cigar wastes no time showing its character. The dark wrapper signals richness, and the flavors back it up—chocolate at the core, rounded out with fruit, spice, and roasted coffee. It leans towards full body but stays easy to enjoy, even if you’re not a seasoned smoker. For the price, it’s a steal: complex, well-made, and far more refined than expected.

EP Carrillo Allegance confidant

The EP Carrillo Allegiance Confidant shows solid balance throughout, with the last third bringing in standout flavors that add a wonderful dynamic twist. The body sits at medium, edging toward full, yet remains approachable enough for less experienced smokers. When it comes to price versus taste and quality, this cigar offers impressive value, delivering more than you’d expect for what you pay.

Eladio Diaz 70 Aniversario cigar

The Eladio Diaz 70 Aniversario is a standout cigar, offering remarkable complexity while maintaining perfect balance. Notes of fruity sweetness, floral tones, licorice, and chocolate weave together beautifully. For what it delivers, the value is outstanding, you truly get a lot of cigar for the money.

Gurkha Seduction robusto

The Gurkha Seduction Robusto delivers solid balance with a distinctive citrus note that shines in the second third. Its body sits between medium and full, making it best suited for the more seasoned aficionado. It’s a cigar that rewards slow smoking, and when you weigh price against flavor and quality, it offers impressive value for the experience.

Hemmy’s Linea secreta

The Hemmy’s Linea Secreta Robusto balances its flavors beautifully, delivering a smooth and approachable complexity. It opens with fruity sweetness that carries through the smoke, finishing with a touch of earthiness for a satisfying close.

Stallone cigars Palamino Connecticut robusto

You might wonder if a 96 rating is too high for a cigar with lighter complexity, but here’s why it earns it. I’ve compared it against countless Connecticut cigars in its price range, and even against premium options at twice the cost and very few deliver this level of quality. The flavors are smooth yet pronounced, showing creamy sweetness with subtle notes of fruit, coffee, and herbs. It burns beautifully when smoked slowly, and the draw is spot on: neither too loose nor too tight.

PDR AFR-75 Cosecha Especial Shade Grown Robusto

The PDR AFR-75 Cosecha Especial Shade Grown Robusto offers a surprisingly smooth, fresh flavor with a refined complexity that shifts beautifully between the thirds. Each note feels well balanced, making it an easy cigar to enjoy. With its mild body, it’s approachable for just about any aficionado. Considering the taste, quality, and price, it delivers exceptional value—I’d gladly pay more for the experience.