The only thing that was hard about reviewing the blackened s84 shade cigar was that I didn’t light another one right after. A conneticut experience i never have had before.
The cigar is a collaboration between Rob Dietrich (mater blender and distiller) at blackened whiskey, music legend James Hetfield (guitarist, singer and one of the founders of Metallica) and the founder of Drew estate cigars Jonathan Drew. I have previously written about how music is a perfect pairing with cigars, but this cigar shows the pairing in a completely different way.
Construction
The bands around the cigar were a perfect example of less is more and gave a somehow powerful impression. It felt a bit like it was a mysterious blend hidden in a humidor, with minimal text to preserve as much of the blend as possible, to be taken out and enjoyed by a lucky few.
The Drew Estate blackened s84 shade was incredibly firmly rolled with a silky smooth oily feeling to it.
Wrapper: Connecticut Ecuador – Binder: Connecticut River Valley Broadleaf Maduro USA – Filler: USA and Nicaragua
Scent and cold draw
The scents I was met with were a bit shocking and incredibly pleasant. The wrapper had a scent of hay and incredibly sweet fruitiness while the filler was a bit extra shocking. I have never before experienced that my thoughts have been taken to peach and vanilla without the cigar having been infused before. A masterpiece I cannot describe. The cold draw was incredibly tasty and worked as an appetizer long before lighting. Something I regretted not doing, that I took more time before. But I was eager to get it lit and see what it had to offer. The cold draw gave me flavors of strangely chamomile tea and peach.
1/3 Lets enjoy the first third of the Drew Estate blackened s84 shade to black toro
When I lit the cigar I was greeted by a silky creamy texture and smooth flavors of coffee with cream, cedar, nuttiness reminiscent of sweet almond and an incredibly sweet Fruitiness that no matter how unreal it sounds with a weaker nuance that is most easily described as peach. In the background there were flavors of carbonation, grass and another flavor nuance that took me by surprise, a tartness that can only be described as a combination of citrus and raspberry. The retrohalation tickled my nose a little lightly and gave nuances of cedar. I can’t say anything other than that I was shocked and almost couldn’t believe my taste buds. An incredibly good start to the cigar.
2/3 Lets enjoy the second third of the Blackened s84
The texture changed a bit and was creamy with a light buttery hint. The flavors I felt were raspberry-like acidity, hay combined with cedar, nuttiness in the sweet almond direction and coffee with cream and sugar. In the background there were flavors of fruitiness that still had nuances of peaches and sweet dried herbs. The retrohalation became smoother but still tickled a little lightly in my nose and gave nuances of cedar.
3/3 Lets see how the Drew estate blackened s84 ends
The texture was as before creamy with a slight hint of butteriness. The flavors I felt in the cigar were Sweet dried herbs, nuttiness in the sweet almond direction, sweet fruitiness with a hint of peach peel, general woodiness, hay and leather. In the background there were nuances of coffee with cream and sugar. Retrohalation was now completely smooth and gave nuances of cedar.
After taste
General woodiness
Body
Medium bordering on mild
Smoke time
85 minutes
Conclusion
Drew estate blackened s84 shade to black toro is a cigar that has an incredibly unique flavor profile. It is incredibly sweet and has some flavors that stand out from the crowd. The body that is on medium makes it suitable for most Aficionados. If I compare price vs taste vs quality I think it is far too low in price and you get much more than what you paid for.
Subscribe to our newsletter and find out about all new posts
Check out our latest posts
- No Sugar Added: The Neuroscience of Why Sweet Cigars Rewire Your Brain
You smell it before you light it. Something about the foot of the cigar — earthy, warm, a little dark — registers as familiar. Comfortable.… Read more: No Sugar Added: The Neuroscience of Why Sweet Cigars Rewire Your Brain - Amar by AJ Fernandez Robusto Review: A Cigar Born From Fire
The Amar by AJ Fernandez Robusto carries a story worth knowing before you light it. In March 2025, a fire tore through Tabacalera AJ Fernandez Cigars de Nicaragua in Estelí, the factory where AJ built his reputation. What followed was an outpouring of support from across the cigar world. Amar is his answer to that […]
- K by Karen Berger 25th Anniversary by AJ Fernandez Review: A Full-Bodied Collaboration Full of Unique Character
The K by Karen Berger 25th Anniversary by AJ Fernandez is a collaboration between Karen Berger and master blender AJ Fernandez, and it smokes with real confidence. This box-pressed Toro delivers a full-bodied, deeply layered profile across 80 minutes, with a handful of unusual flavor nuances that set it apart from almost anything else in […]
- Don Kiki Brown Label Barber Pole Figurado Review: A Small Cigar With Big Character
The Don Kiki Brown Label Barber Pole Figurado shows how much character a short cigar can carry. This compact figurado from Karen Berger’s Nicaraguan brand… Read more: Don Kiki Brown Label Barber Pole Figurado Review: A Small Cigar With Big Character - Gilbert de Montsalvat Anniversary Gran Robusto Review: A Sweet, Complex Value cigar
The Gilbert de Montsalvat Anniversary Gran Robusto is a genuine pleasure to smoke. It arrives with a beautifully twisted pigtail cap and a closed foot, settles into a leisurely 80 minutes, and works through a sweet, layered profile of vanilla bean, nutmeg, and old-fashioned caramel. This is a cigar with real character, and one that […]
- Why Does My Cigar Taste Metallic?
Sometimes it’s barely there. A faint, stony note woven into an otherwise rich profile, the kind of thing you’d only catch if you were paying… Read more: Why Does My Cigar Taste Metallic? - Stauffenberg Cigars: The Complete Guide, Reviews, Interview and the Story Behind the Brand
Stauffenberg Cigars is a Honduran-rooted premium brand founded by Maik Neubauer as a tribute to the resistance fighters of the Second World War. Every edition… Read more: Stauffenberg Cigars: The Complete Guide, Reviews, Interview and the Story Behind the Brand - Don Kiki Green Label Toro Review: A mild cigar from Karen Berger
Not every cigar needs to demand your full attention. The Don Kiki Green Label Toro, from Karen Berger’s long-running Nicaraguan brand, is a mild, well-built… Read more: Don Kiki Green Label Toro Review: A mild cigar from Karen Berger
